Targeting the Few Bad Agents in A Growing Toronto Real Estate Market Posted onMay 11, 2017June 23, 2020/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Toronto’s real estate market is currently facing unprecedented growth. Hefty real estate commissions and a lagging economy in other job areas have attracted many people to the career of a real estate agent. While the majority of agents complete a transaction in the client’s best interest, it is clear that there are not enough legal regulations to protect the public from the few bad apples in the bunch who complete deals for their own financial gain. One example of the perfectly legal but shady practice is a “double-ending deal”— i.e. where the real estate agent represents both the buyer and the seller, collecting a commission from each side. While double-ended deals can be fine if the agent clearly communicates their role, conflicts and what they can and cannot do, these types of transactions expose both sides to a high level of risk that their agent may not be acting ethically. Not only do these transactions give rise to conflicting duties to the client (and it is unclear which client the agent is fully advocating for), they can result in both sides paying more for the transaction, despite the agent’s promise of a lower commission rate. Last November, a CBC Marketplace investigation revealed six real estate agents making promises in clear violation of the Real Estate Council of Ontario’s regulation and Code of Ethics. Captured on hidden cameras, the agents promised open house walk-ins that if they chose to use them (the seller’s agent) to buy the property, they could “control the sale” guaranteeing that the buyers would win the home purchase or that they would use insider information to leverage their offer over others. Another concern is about agents who offer “exclusive listing” sales where the buyer’s agent encourages them not to put their home on the open market but instead sell it within the agent’s pool of potential buyers. The research is clear: higher prices are obtained for homes that are placed on the open market. Usually, the one to two percent savings that the agent offers to buyers willing to go through these transactions is paltry compared to the higher price they would have seen on the open market (see this Huffington Post article). Sellers should always be the ones to decide when the solicitation of offers ends. A buyer should be wary if their agent pushes for “one-and-done” offer rounds or to avoid multiple rounds during a bidding war. If the seller’s agent also represents the buyer they should present their own client’s offer first, not last. Other red flags are poor or non-existent photography in the MLS listing (which makes open house walk-ins the primary way of selling the property) or lack of communication with interested buyers (which dissuades growing interest in the property). While I agree with some commentators’ position that an outright ban on double-ended transactions would offer an easily-enforceable solution, I also believe that more should be done to raise the standards of entry for the profession as a whole. Right now, it only takes 213 hours to become a licensed real estate sales professional and the focus of the model is on individual agents, instead of the brokerage as a whole. Placing more responsibility on the brokerage to oversee their agents’ conduct is also a solution that should be considered. With that being said, the best protection from the few unscrupulous agents in the industry is buyers and sellers who know their rights and how to spot practices that raise red flags. If you are in need of a real estate lawyer, please visit our website and contact one of our real estate lawyers today. If you are in need of any other services or have any questions, you may also contact our Toronto office directly at 416-449-1400. “This article is intended to inform and entertain. Its content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon by readers as such. If you require legal assistance, please see a lawyer. Each case is unique and a lawyer with good training and sound judgment can provide you with advice tailored to your specific situation and needs.” Related Posts Posted onSeptember 30, 2020April 22, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Title Insurance Providers Introduce Increased Protection for Lenders from Super Priority Liens and Deemed Trusts The recent decision of the Federal Court of Appeal in Toronto-Dominion Bank v Canada, 2020 FCA 80 (“TD v Canada”), created a new cause for concern for lenders. The facts of the case are as follows: In 2007 and 2008 the debtor, before becoming a customer of the Toronto-Dominion Bank (“TD”), failed to remit to [...] Read more Posted onAugust 18, 2020June 4, 2021/ Laura Rosati Four things you need to know about “Time shall be of the essence” in real estate transactions (especially in a pandemic!) A contract of sale for a piece of real estate property will almost always expressly provide that time is of the essence. This clause means that you and the other parties in the agreement must be punctual and fulfill their obligations promptly. Otherwise, if you fail to perform in a timely fashion, the contract may end [...] Read more Posted onApril 12, 2019July 5, 2023/ Robert P. Adourian What happens if I default on my Mortgage? A mortgage on your home will most likely be the most significant debt you will incur in your lifetime. A commitment in which you will be obligated to pay for a considerable amount of time – in the majority of cases anywhere between 10-30 years. That said, when a borrower defaults on their loan and [...] Read more Posted onAugust 30, 2018June 16, 2020/ Larry W. Keown and Katelyn Bell Supreme Court Refuses Leave to Appeal: Toronto Real Estate Agents Must Publish Data On Thursday, August 23 2018, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) declined to hear an appeal that has been over seven years in the making. For the last seven years, the Toronto Real Estate Board (TREB) and the Competition Bureau have been litigating over the issue of sales-data policies. It all began when the Competition [...] Read more Posted onDecember 12, 2017June 17, 2020/ Devry Smith Frank LLP National Housing Strategy On Wednesday, November 23, Justin Trudeau announced the federal government’s 10 year national housing strategy. The federal housing strategy is aimed at ensuring that Canadians have access to affordable homes. The aim is to reduce poverty and homelessness. Trudeau deemed access to adequate housing as a “human right”. The federal government is hoping to make [...] Read more