Do I Have to Give Half Our House to My Ex-Spouse Even Though I Paid for it Myself? Posted onNovember 19, 2019August 12, 2024/ Katelyn Bell With the rising costs of housing in the GTA, the question of what happens to property after divorce can loom heavily on those who enter into marriage with significant assets. In Ontario, the Family Law Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3, (the “FLA”) is the legislation that governs the property rights of separating spouses including the “equalization of net family property”. Generally speaking, the purpose of equalization is to calculate the value of assets accumulated during the course of the marriage and to have it divided equally between the spouses, subject to exclusions such as gifts and inheritances. However, it does not actually change the ownership interest of the property itself. There are special rules that apply to the matrimonial home which is property where at the time of separation was “ordinarily occupied by the person and his or her spouse as their family residence”. Even if only one party owned the matrimonial home prior to marriage, the full net value of the home is equalized. This leads to the question: is it worth it to get a marriage contract (also known as a pre-nuptial agreement) to protect your property that you purchased prior to marriage and are now using as the matrimonial home? In Martin v. Watts, 2018 ONSC 2622, clauses in the parties’ marriage contract regarding the division of their matrimonial home upon relationship dissolution were upheld. The wife in this case used her assets to purchase a property that would become their matrimonial home. The parties entered into a marriage contract in 1990 that stipulated if the parties separated, the wife would receive a return of her cash contribution plus 25% free of any claim by the husband, with the balance divided equally. This provision would apply when there was a sale or buy out of the matrimonial home. The husband brought a motion to have the matrimonial home sold and for him to be given carriage of the sale. He relied on s. 52(2) of the FLA, which provides that “a provision in a marriage contract purporting to limit a spouse’s rights under Part II (Matrimonial home) is unenforceable.” However, the motion judge upheld the marriage contract and reminded the husband that the FLA does not actually create ownership rights so he does not have the authority to force the sale of the home. As long as the “intent of the contract is sufficiently clear, a domestic contract may provide an exemption from the equalization provisions of the legislation”. In other words, a carefully worded marriage contract could protect your property from equalization even when it is the matrimonial home. For more information on the specific wording required, speak to certified family law specialist Katelyn Bell on 416-446-5837 “This article is intended to inform. Its content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon by readers as such. If you require legal assistance, please see a lawyer. Each case is unique and a lawyer with good training and sound judgment can provide you with advice tailored to your specific situation and needs.” This blog is co-written by articling student, Janet Son. Authors Katelyn Bell 416-446-5837 416-446-5837 katelyn.bell@devrylaw.ca Related Posts Posted onJanuary 25, 2021February 16, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Can My New Spouse or Partner Adopt My Biological Children? Integrating a new partner into your existing family can be an exciting step, but it is not always without challenges. Depending on whether the children’s other biological parent is still in the picture, your children’s age, and their opinion, the process of adoption could be difficult and you may face additional legal challenges. Is the [...] Read more Posted onJanuary 25, 2021August 12, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Why You Might Want A Cohabitation Agreement Granted, it is not a particularly romantic gesture to ask your common-law partner for a cohabitation agreement. If you are busy building a happy life together, bringing up the possibility of separation and legal consequences that may result can be uncomfortable. Here are several reasons why that discomfort should be faced, overcome, and how your [...] Read more Posted onDecember 24, 2020August 12, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Sharing The Holidays After Separation Holidays can be difficult for separated families. It may be impossible for the children to celebrate with both parents and their families or to have the most important time, that is, Christmas morning, with both parents. So how can separated parents divide up those special times? Doing so can be one of the biggest challenges [...] Read more Posted onDecember 17, 2020August 27, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Can I Be Summoned to Pay My Fiancé’s Child Support in Ontario? Question: I am engaged to someone who already has kids from a previous marriage: 6, 13 and 14 years. If he defaults on his child support payment, will I be asked to pay his support? Will my income be factored in? How can I protect myself? – Advice Scene Child support is the right of [...] Read more Posted onSeptember 25, 2020August 12, 2024/ Devry Smith Frank LLP Determining the Child Support Obligations of a Step Parent A spouse who stands in the place of a parent to a child can be obligated to pay child support, according to s. 5 of the Ontario Child Support Guidelines (“Guidelines”). The amount a step-parent will be ordered to pay is at the discretion of courts. When exercising this discretion, the court will look to [...] Read more